Most Recent Publications

 

Brandishing dangerous weapons during strike action and proving employees’ awareness of the rule prohibiting this conduct

By Sean Jamieson, Senior Associate, Michael Bailey, Candidate Attorney, Employment, Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr

 

In the recent case of Pailpac (Pty) Ltd v De Beer N.O and Others (DA 12/2018) [2021] ZALAC 3 (1 March 2021), the Labour Appeal Court (LAC) was tasked with assessing this scenario. In July 2014, NUMSA embarked on a national strike in the metal and engineering industry. The affected employees were dismissed for carrying dangerous weapons during the strike including sticks, PVC rods, sjamboks and golf clubs.

 

The employees challenged the fairness of their dismissals at the bargaining council. The arbitrator found that the employees were unfairly dismissed for a rule that they “did not know existed, or which was not effectively communicated to them”.

 

The employer took the award on review at the Labour Court (LC). The LC dismissed the review application, prompting the employer to take the matter on appeal at the LAC. The primary issue for the LAC’s determination was whether the employees knew or could reasonably have been expected to be aware of the rule (prohibiting the brandishing of dangerous weapons).

 

The employer’s argument had two legs in respect of what evidence it contended the arbitrator had unreasonably ignored. Firstly, the dismissed employees knew that the employer’s rules prohibited the carrying of sticks, sjamboks and golf clubs in a hostile fashion during a strike. Secondly, the material contradictions in the versions of the dismissed employees regarding their knowledge of the rules and the notice board where the rules were published.

 

In contrast, the dismissed employees contended that there was no evidence that they were aware of the rules. While the rules were displayed on the notice board at the main entrance of the employer’s factory, the employees disputed having read the rules. However, they conceded to reading other information previously placed on the very same notice board.

 

The LAC therefore found that it is “probable” that the employees were aware of the rule or could reasonably have been expected to be aware of the rule. Accordingly, the arbitrator’s finding was not one that could reasonably be reached.

 

The LAC also rejected the employees’ defence that they were prevented from approaching the wall where the rules could be read. Accordingly, if the dismissed employees were able to approach the wall, it is probable that they would have been able to read the rule that prohibited the brandishing of dangerous weapons. Importantly, the LAC reiterated that the test is not whether the employees had approached the wall to read the rules, but whether the dismissed employees were aware of the rule or could reasonably have been expected to be aware of the rule.

 

The LAC held that “the breach of the rule by the dismissed employees coupled with the ensuing harm to, and intimidation of, non-striking employees rendered their continued employment intolerable and made dismissal an appropriate sanction.” Accordingly, the dismissals were substantively fair.

 

This judgment provides clarity on the appropriate test to be applied when an employee’s knowledge of a rule is disputed, namely whether the employee was aware of the rule or could reasonably have been expected to be aware of the rule.

 

For more information contact Sean Jamieson at [email protected]

 

Article published with the kind courtesy of Cliffe Dekker Hofmeyr www.cliffedekkerhofmeyr.com

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Subscribe to our free newsletter

* indicates required
 

By submitting your email address to us, you agree to receive our newsletters and course updates. For more information about how we protect your personal information, click here .

Accredited Training Provider

     

Upcoming Courses

 

Workplace Discipline and Dismissal

07 July 2022 (09:00 - 16:00)

Interactive Online Course

Health and Safety Representative and Committee Training Course

14 July 2022 (08:30 - 16:00)

Interactive Online Course

21 July 2022 (08:30 - 16:00)

Emperors Palace Convention Centre

Basic Labour Relations

15 July 2022 (09:00 - 16:00)

Interactive Online Course

New Code of Good Practice: Harassment in the Workplace New Course

15 July 2022 (09:00 - 12:00)

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

Chairing Disciplinary Hearings

21 & 22 July 2022 (09:00 - 16:00)

Interactive Online Course

The OHS Act and the Responsibilities of Management (Legal Liability) 

28 July 2022 (08:30 - 16:00)

Interactive Online Course

29 July 2022 (08:30 – 16:00)

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre 

Managing day-to-day challenges in the workplace

28 July 2022 (09:00 - 15:30)

Interactive Online Course

The Basic Conditions of Employment Act and Related Workplace Policies New Course

29 July 2022 (08:30 - 12:30)

Interactive Online Course 

 

August

New Code of Good Practice: Harassment in the Workplace New Course

04 August 2022 (09:00 - 12:00)

Interactive Online Course

Trade Unions in the Workplace

05 August 2022 (09:00 - 12:00)

Interactive Online Course

Managing day-to-day challenges in the workplace

12 August 2022 (09:00 - 15:30)

Cape Town: Protea Hotel Tyger Valley

The formulation of disciplinary charges Online Course

12 August 2022 (09:00 - 12:00)

Interactive Online Course

Chairing Disciplinary Hearings

18 & 19 August 2022 (09:00 - 16:00)

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

Hazard Identification & Risk Assessment Course

18 August 2022 (08:30 - 16:00)

Interactive Online Course

Shop Steward Training

19 August 2022 (09:00 - 16:00)

Interactive Online Course 

How to win an unfair dismissal case at the CCMA / Bargaining Council

25 August 2022 (09:00 - 16:00)

Interactive Online Course

Managing Poor Performance/ Incapacity

25 August 2022 (09:00 - 13:00)

Interactive Online Course

Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases Course

26 August 2022 (08:30 - 16:00)

Interactive Online Course

 

September

Retrenchments Simplified

02 September 2022 (09:00 - 12:00)

Interactive Online Course

Introduction to Mediation New Course

08 September 2022 (09:00 - 16:00)

Interactive Online Course

Basic Labour Relations

09 September 2022 (09:00 - 16:00)

Cape Town: Protea Hotel Tyger Valley

Negotiation Skills New Course

22 September 2022 (08:30 - 16:00)

Interactive Online Course

 

Our Clients