Discipline and Dismissal

Andrew Smith and Robyn Hugo

Bowman Gilfillan Attorneys


A few weeks ago, Andre van Niekerk, Judge of the Labour Court, delivered a judgment affecting the suspension of public sector employees. The judgment is equally relevant for private sector employees. In Mogothle v the Premier of the North West Province and the MEC for Agriculture, Conservation and Environment, the Deputy Director General (DDG) of the Department of Agriculture, Conservation and Development in the North West Province apparently approved a state grant to an entity in which he and his family had an interest.


The DDG claimed that he had nothing to do with the decision to allocate the grant but, being concerned about the implications of a conflict of interest, he made full disclosure to the MEC. The MEC acknowledged his disclosure and approved the grant. Subsequent debate in the North West Provincial Legislature resulted in the DDG being placed on "extended leave" pending various investigations.


In suspending the DDG, the MEC expressly disavowed a reliance on the provisions of the Senior Management Service (SMS) Handbook. The suspension was framed as a "request" that the DDG take leave in order to allow the investigation to unfold without the risk of it being jeopardised by the DDG's presence at work. The DDG was not given the opportunity to make representations on why he should not be suspended.

 

In seeking to have his suspension uplifted, the DDG faced several obstacles:

  • His employment, as with all senior governmental employees, was governed by the SMS Handbook, which was silent on whether he was allowed to make representations prior to being suspended.
  •  A recent Constitutional Court case (the Chirwa case) has held, in effect, that a public sector employee does not, at least in the context of challenging a dismissal, have the right to approach the High Court (or the Labour Court directly) for what is really an employment matter. Such an employee should refer his or her dispute to the CCMA or relevant bargaining council for adjudication.

      

The DDG chose the Labour Court, and relied on the so-called audi principle – a contractual right to be heard before a decision adverse to your rights or interests is taken.The judge had to decide whether the DDG was required to use his Labour Relations Act (LRA) rights rather than his contractual rights. Should the DDG's case be decided in the Labour Court, or should the DDG rather have challenged his suspension as an unfair labour practice at the relevant bargaining council?

         

The DDG expressly declined to rely on the LRA. Rather, he relied on a contractual right: effectively that the MEC and the Premier had breached their contractual obligation to deal fairly with him. The judge decided that Chirwa did not remove contractual rights which an employee can enforce either in the Labour Court or the High Court. This meant that he was able to consider the DDG's claim in the Labour Court. The conclusion: without having been afforded a hearing, the DDG's suspension was procedurally unfair.

         

The Chirwa judgment appears to require labour-related matters, which are principally about fairness, to be determined in terms of the LRA mechanisms. The Mogothle judgment might have the opposite effect and unravel the distinction between litigation in the High Court and in terms of the LRA.

         

Andrew Smith is a senior associate in the corporate law department and Robyn Hugo is a senior associate in the employment law department at Bowman Gilfillan

  • Our appreciation to Bowman Gilfillan for permission to publish this article.
  • For more information visit http://www.bowman.co.za  

Case Law Summaries and Articles

 

Can employees be dismissed for refusing to accept new terms and conditions of employment?

Can an employer dismiss employees because they refuse to agree to a change to their terms and conditions of employment? An initial answer may be, “yes”.

Read More >>>

 

Escape route: “Resignation with immediate effect”

The latest case in the ‘disciplining employees who have resigned with immediate effect’ saga has brought about more uncertainty as to whether an employee who resigns with immediate effect shortly before a disciplinary hearing can avoid disciplinary action and subsequent dismissal.

Read More >>>

 

Freedom of expression or incitement to commit an offence? A constitutional challenge

On 4 July 2019, the North Gauteng High Court handed down judgment in the case of The EFF and other v Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development and other (87638/2017 and 45666/2017) in which the EFF and Julius Malema (the applicants) sought to have s18(2)(b) of the Riotous Assemblies Act, No 17 of 1956 (Riotous Act) declared unconstitutional.

Read More >>>

 

Consolidated, comprehensive or general final written warnings

Regarding dismissal, according to the Code of Good Practice, “the courts have endorsed the concept of corrective or progressive discipline. This approach regards the purpose of discipline as a means for employees to know and understand what standards are required of them.

Read More >>>

 

 

 

 

 

 

Courses and Workshops

 

                                         

 
 

Shop Steward Training

28 August 2019

Emperors Palace Convention Centre

Employment Equity Committee Training

29 August 2019 (Fully Booked)

Tsogo Sun: Century City: Cape Town

30 August 2019

Tsogo Sun: Century City: Cape Town

27 September 2019

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

04 October 2019

Southern Sun: Maharani: Durban

Basic Labour Relations

04 September 2019

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

Compensation for Occupational Injuries and Diseases Course

12 September 2019

Southern Sun: Maharani Towers: Durban

The OHS Act and the Responsibilities of Management

13 September 2019

Southern Sun: Maharani Towers: Durban

19 September 2019

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

28 November 2019

Protea Hotel By Marriott Tyger Valley: Cape Town

Managing Day to Day Issues/ Problem Employees Full day workshop

20 September 2019

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

27 September 2019

Tsogo Sun: Century City: Cape Town

AARTO and the Impact on Your Business

03 October 2019

Emperors Palace Convention Centre

Hazard Identification & Risk Assessment Course

18 October 2019

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

21 November 2019

Tsogo Sun: Century City: Stay Easy: Cape Town

Workshop Incident/Accident Investigation Course

25 October 2019

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

22 November 2019

Tsogo Sun: Century City: Stay Easy: Cape Town

  

 Our Clients 

 

Android App On Google Play

Android App On Google Play