Most Recent Publications

Breaking News



Withholding or Deducting an Employee’s Pension Benefit – Recent legal developments

By Carlyle Field, Partner in the Pension Law department, Shepstone & Wylie Attorneys

 

The Pension Funds Act provides a method for employers to recover compensation for damages caused by the theft, dishonesty, fraud or misconduct of an employee.  In certain circumstances the compensation is recovered from the pension benefits payable to the erring employee, upon his or her withdrawal from the fund.  Employers and funds that implement these deductions should take careful note of recent case law that may have drastically changed the landscape of these deductions.

 

The common understanding has always been that the conduct of the erring employee was required to constitute theft, fraud, or other dishonest misconduct (which would accordingly exclude pure negligence).  This understanding arose from the High Court decision in 2009 of Moodley v Local Transitional Council of Scottburgh Umzinto North & Another where it was decided that the term “misconduct” as used in the Pension Funds Act had to be determined with reference to other specific words used, in particular “dishonesty”.  The Gauteng High Court in the case of Kwachu Pension Fund & Another v Pension Funds Adjudicator & Another) recently issued a judgment which appears to extend the test developed in the Moodley case.  The Gauteng court (in overturning the determination of the Pension Funds Adjudicator) concluded that “the actions of the member in retaining the employer’s vehicle after having undertaken to return same…falls squarely within the ambit of misconduct by the member”.  There was no reference to dishonesty.  This would appear to be a deviation from the conclusion reached in the Moodley decision in 2009, namely that misconduct must incorporate an element of dishonesty in order for the fund to be permitted to deduct monies from the member’s fund benefit and pay this over to the employer.

 

In another recent judgment by the same division of the High Court in Denel SOC Limited t/a Denel Aviation & Another v Klaas Madimetsa Mafalo & Another, the Judge ruled that the member had been unjustly enriched by a payroll error that resulted in him being overpaid by nearly R2 million.  Although the Judge accepted the finding in the employer’s internal disciplinary proceedings that gross dishonesty had been committed, he refused to make a special costs order on this basis, but nevertheless permitted the deduction from the member’s pension benefits to repay some of the salary overpayment.  It is surprising that the deduction was authorised in the absence of a court ruling that dishonest misconduct had been committed. 

 

We eagerly await to see which approach is adopted in future when determining the ambit of misconduct in these withholding cases.

 

For more information kindly contact Carlyle Field at This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Article published with the kind courtesy of Shepstone & Wylie Attorneys for more information please visit http://www.wylie.co.za 

 

 

 

 

Courses and Workshops

Our Clients

 

Managing Day to Day Issues/ Problem Employees Full day workshop

29 September 2017

Southern Sun: Elangeni & Maharani, Elangeni Towers: Durban

13 October 2017

Southern Sun: OR Tambo International Airport

Workshop Policies and Procedures

05 October 2017

Southern Sun: OR Tambo International Airport

Basic Labour Relations

06 October 2017

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

Skills Development Committee Training

12 October 2017

Southern Sun/Tsogo Sun Hotel: Or Tambo International Airport

19 October 2017

Protea Hotel By Marriott Tyger Valley: Cape Town

Workshop Chairing Disciplinary Hearings

12 & 13 October 2017

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

Skills Development Legislation and Review

18 October 2017

Protea Hotel By Marriott Tyger Valley: Cape Town

26 October 2017

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

The OHS Act and the Responsibilities of Management

27 October 2017

Southern Sun/Tsogo Sun Hotel : Or Tambo International Airport

17 November 2017

Protea Hotel By Marriott Tyger Valley: Cape Town

Health and Safety Representative Course

03 November 2017

Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

15 November 2017

Protea Hotel By Marriott Tyger Valley: Cape Town

Occupational injuries and diseases in the workplace

08 November 2017

Southern Sun/Tsogo Sun Hotel : Or Tambo International Airport

16 November 2017

Protea Hotel By Marriott Tyger Valley: Cape Town