Conditions of Employment
  • Workplace Discipline
  • Contracts of Employment
  • Breaking News

    


    Employers who do not keep detailed records of disciplinary action taken against employees for misconduct, including the action taken and sanctions imposed, take a huge risk. Time and time again, it has been shown just how vital proper record keeping is in regard to coming out on top at the CCMA.


    In Gcwensha v CCMA & others, the employee had been dismissed for gross negligence, and the employers excellent record-keeping showed that the employee had a number of previous warnings for incompetence, negligence and inefficiency.


    At the time of his dismissal, the employee was on a current warning, which had the effect of placing him on terms. The court found that the employee had a " deplorable record" which the employer was entitled to consider when deciding on a suitable sanction for the current transgression.The employers excellent record-keeping saved the day.

     

    In NUMSA v John Thompson Africa (Pty) Ltd [1997] 7 BLLR 932 (CCMA), it was the lack of proper record-keeping that landed the employer in trouble, and ended up with a reinstated employee. The employee was dismissed for wilful damage to and deliberate misuse of company property, using abusive language, and being under the influence of an intoxicating substance.


    The employee followed his employer's appeal procedure, but no record of the proceedings at the disciplinary hearing was available for the appeal chairperson. Since there was no record of the evidence led at the disciplinary hearing, there was no evidence to indicate that the employment relationship had been irretrievably harmed by the employee's behaviour. The employee was reinstated.

     

    Schedule 8 - the Code of Good Practice - Dismissal requires that the employers must keep records of all disciplinary action taken against employees, the reason for it, and the outcome of that disciplinary action. The chairperson of a disciplinary hearing cannot apply his mind properly to the problem if there is no record of alleged previous disciplinary actions against the employee. Obviously, the employee with a clean disciplinary record is the exception - there is no record to consider.

     

    However, the chairperson is placed in a very difficult position when the employer submits as an aggravating circumstance, or perhaps in  closing arguments, that " this employee is always misconducting himself and has had previous disciplinary hearings", but when the chairperson calls for the previous disciplinary record it is found that there is no record to produce.


    Such an employer goes to the CCMA with very little ammunition - and his case turns out to be rather something of a damp squib. There can be no doubt that meticulous record-keeping and proper preparation is 90% of the battle in CCMA matters.


    Poor record-keeping can result in only one thing - sloppy preparation. And in such circumstances, you have lost before you even start.

    For further information, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

    DVD: How to Deal with Retrenchments

    DVD: How to deal with Retrenchments is now available.

    Click here for more information or to watch a preview.

    Newsletter Signup

    Join more than 70 000 subscribers by simply entering your email address in the text area. Subscription to the newsletter is free of charge, you will be able to unsubscribe anytime without any obligation.

    Android App On Google Play

    Courses and Workshops

    Occupational injuries and diseases in the workplace

    03 March 2015(Fully Booked)

    Southern Sun: Elangeni & Maharani, Elangeni Towers: Durban

    06 March 2015(Fully Booked)

    Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

    20 March 2015(Fully Booked)

    Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

    24 March 2015

    Southern Sun: OR Tambo International Airport

    26 March 2015(Fully Booked)

    Southern Sun: Century City(Canal Walk): Cape Town

    27 March 2015

    Southern Sun: Century City(Canal Walk): Cape Town

    06 May 2015

    Protea Hotel: Edward: Durban

    The OHS Act and the Responsibilities of Management

    04 March 2015

    Southern Sun: Elangeni & Maharani, Elangeni Towers: Durban

    16 April 2015

    Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

    Employment Equity Committee Training

    05 March 2015(Fully Booked)

    Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

    12 March 2015

    Southern Sun: Century City(Canal Walk): Cape Town

    19 March 2015

    Southern Sun: Elangeni & Maharani, Elangeni Towers: Durban

    25 March 2015

    Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

    New Amendments to Labour Legislation

    06 March 2015

    Southern Sun: Elangeni & Maharani, Elangeni Towers: Durban

    12 March 2015(Fully Booked)

    Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

    13 March 2015(Fully Booked)

    Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

    20 March 2015

    Southern Sun: Century City: Cape Town

    27 March 2015

    Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

    Construction Regulation Course

    11 March 2015

    Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

    Workshop Policies and Procedures

    19 March 2015

    Southern Sun: Century City: Cape Town

    10 April 2015

    Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

    Health and Safety Representative Course

    25 March 2015

    Southern Sun: Century City(Canal Walk): Cape Town

    26 March 2015

    Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

    Workshop Chairing Disciplinary Hearings

    26 & 27 March 2015

    Emperors Palace: Convention Centre

    23 & 24 April 2015

    Southern Sun: Century City(Canal Walk): Cape Town

    07 & 08 May 2015

    Protea Hotel: Edward: Durban

    Managing Day to Day Issues/ Problem Employees Full day workshop

    15 April 2015

    Southern Sun: OR Tambo International Airport

    22 April 2015

    Southern Sun: Century City(Canal Walk): Cape Town

    06 May 2015

    Protea Hotel: Edward : Durban